- 1 time IEF TV Champion with Jeff Hardy
- 1 time WTW Extreme TV Champion with Randy Orton
- 1 time WTW Royal Rumble Winner (2013) with Randy Orton
- 1 time WFR Elimination Chamber Winner (2012) with Jeff Hardy
- 1 time OWF World Heavyweight Champion with Jeff Hardy
- 1 time OWF Tag Team Champion with Jeff Hardy (w/Matt Hardy)
- 1 time GWE Intercontinental Champion with Mark Henry
- 1 time GWE Tag Team Champion with Sami Zayn (w/Ricochet)
- 2 times WFR World Heavyweight Champion with Jeff Hardy (longest reign ever)
- 2 time EWS Slobber Knocker Champion with The Wils
- 2 times FW World Heavyweight Champion with The Miz (longest reign ever)
- 1 time EWS Tag Team Champion with The Wils (w/Unstable Axel)
- 1 time IWE Hardcore Champion with The Wils
- 1 time FW Champion with The Miz
- 1 time FWIO FWIO Champion with Brock Lesnar
- 2 time FWF Intercontinental Champion with Wils/Ricochet
- 1 time WWI WWE Champion with Brock Lesnar
- 1 time WNI Intercontinental Champion with Wils/Bray Wyatt
- 2 time EWS True Berserk Champion with The Wils
- 1 time NWR Light Heavyweight/OpenWeight Champion with The Wils
- 1 time FWIO Tag Team Champion with Goldust (w/Cody Rhodes)
- EWS Hot Spot of the year 2015/2016
- 1 time IMW/WFE Italian Champion with Wils/Bray Wyatt
- 1 time IWF Tag Team Champion with D-Von Dudley (w/Bubba Ray Dudley)
- 1 time AW Hardcore Champion with Paul Heyman
- 1 time FFI World Heavyweight Champion with Jeff Hardy
- 1 time HWE Champion with CM Punk
- 1 time WIW World Heavyweight Champion with AJ Styles
- 1 time FWF Champion with Wils/Ricochet
- 1 time AWF Champion with Willow